
Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol is a story that requires little introduction. It’s a story that’s been interpreted on screen through traditional live action, to cartoons to muppets. And so up steps Robert Zemeckis, following on from his 3D CGI forays of The Polar Express and Beowulf, to take a run at this classic festive tale in his preferred medium.
Robert Zemeckis doesn’t use straight CGI (such as Pixar), rather he uses motion capture that requires his actors to deliver performances that are then stored in computer, overlaid with new cosmetics and delivered all-singing and dancing to the big screen. Jim Carrey here takes on the main role of Scrooge, but is also on duty as the ghosts of Christmas Past and Present, as well as other roles.

It’s a curious style. Jim Carrey is mostly recognisable as Scrooge and delivers a clipped, sneering performance of this most famous of characters. Personally I thought the part was a little under-nourished. His transformation from miserly to generosity is the crux of the story, yet Scrooge here seems to turn around and be open to change from as early as the first ghostly visitation. Frankly, you get the feeling that Scrooge would have been amenable for changing his ways after he had been shown Christmas pasts and they needn’t have bothered going the whole hog with Christmas present and future.
Whilst Carrey certainly takes his lion’s share of the parts he is not alone; Gary Oldman does good work in multiple roles as Bob Cratchett and Jacob Marley, but this is counterbalanced by the likes of Colin Firth and Bob Hoskins who, through know fault of their own, appear on screen as malformed versions of the person you recognise that is more jarring than entertaining.
The real issue with this version of A Christmas Carol is that the 3D CGI thrills and spills of it all are both its biggest draw and biggest drawback. It is, in effect, a display of style over substance. Narrative and character are pencilled in, joining the dots, between the next swooping rush over chimney rooftops, through trees in fields of white snow, even down drainpipes serving as bizarre waterslides.

Zemeckis can take credit for producing a genuinely amazing-looking effect. An early opening sweep over Victorian London, with snow falling in layered depth whilst a boundless ‘camera’ peeks through windows and skirts up close to various people is giddily fantastic. At one point I turned to Mrs. Comet as she turned to me and, with our big 3D glasses on, we grinned at the experience of it.
As a film, in terms of character, script and narrative momentum this version of A Christmas Carol, whilst striving to remain true to the book, doesn’t pack the magic other versions have mustered. The plight of Tiny Tim didn’t strike a chord with me, nor the lost love of Scrooge’s past. It was almost like the film took for granted its audience’s no-doubt familiarity with the tale and so didn’t bother trying to explain every nuance of the story.
But, as a big-screen 3D experience, with its state-of-the-art visuals and menacing scares that will give many a child a scary (but not too scary) time, I can certainly recommend it. Making it a Christmas treat for yourself and your loved ones, making an event of it, that I can endorse. But for any other kind of viewing I say. . . predictably. . . bah humbug!







































